Community Roofing & Restoration Reviews From Area Homeowners

When you need a new roof, windows, doors, or siding, you can count on Community Roofing & Restoration to do it right.

We’re rated as one of the best Milwaukee metro roofing businesses. Check out some of our Google reviews below or schedule a quick onsite quote online or call 414-332-1139 anytime!

EXCELLENT Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5
272 reviews
Posted on Google Google
Joseph Chang
July 30, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I selected Community because I wanted a premium job. This is a rental property. I know many landlords seek the cheapest available, but I believe in doing the most important jobs right the first time. Quality and service cost, but they are 100% worth it over time. They were competitively priced, and Josh paid close attention to my concerns and addressed them all. Their team was in close touch with me and communication was excellent throughout the entire process. I could not recommend them highly enough
Posted on Google Google
Samantha Canning
July 29, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had a great experience with community roofing! Frame the start Paul was very clear in explaining what was wrong with my roof and how they would fix it. Once the work started Chuy also communicated what to expect and any adjustments they needed to do. Great experience and my new roof has been great!
Posted on Google Google
Lisa Celebre
July 24, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Best contractors I've dealt with and I have remodeled two houses. Great customer service and excellent quality of work.
Posted on Google Google
Kim Zick
July 19, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Community Roofing did a fantastic job on my new roof and gutters. Superior customer service from Paul, Chuy and crew!
Posted on Google Google
Pat Calvey
July 17, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We are so glad we chose Community Roofing & Restoration to replace our roof. They definitely are a quality company & very easy to work with. Chuy & his crew were excellent!
Posted on Google Google
Catherine Alequin
July 14, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
David Aldape did an outstanding job with the Roof and gutters of my house. He is committed on getting the job done beautifully. He gave me feedback of the best color of shingles for my house. And he was spot on; my house looks like it got a facelift. Even the neighbors who were checking out the job gave us feedback on the great job his crew did. Also, he is very detailed oriented on when it comes to documenting the inspection report for home insurances. As a veteran he has experience working with USAA documentation process. Thanks Community Roofing and Restoration. I’ll definitely be back for the doors and windows installation.
Posted on Google Google
Dorothy Man
July 13, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
From the initial fair quote to the beautifully installed roof, our experience with the Community Roofing and Restoration team was superb. David, as our point of contact, had exhaustive knowledge of the roofing installation procedure, including hail and wind damage (which he assisted us with filing an insurance claim). He was always responsive to any and all inquiries we had. He truly wears this company in his heart and with pride. Roberto, the project leader, had his team on the job promptly at 7:00 a.m. to prep, tear off old roof, remove gutters, and start laying the new roof before the end of day 1. Day 2, they completed the roof, installed the gutters, and thoroughly cleaned the worksite. The teams worked together to finished our roofing project without any delays and project hiccups. We are very pleased with our roof! Thank you Team Community Roofing & Restoration!
Posted on Google Google
Jon B
July 11, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Really impressed with the timely response, kindness, patience and most importantly quality of work received by David, Roberto and their crew. Highly recommend.
Posted on Google Google
Mark Bialou
July 11, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Roberto and Jeremy from Community Roofing & Restoration did a great job repairing our commercial roof. They identified the issue and found the source of the leaks. They were incredibly professional and made sure the job was done right. Would highly recommend!
Posted on Google Google
Kevin Peterson
July 11, 2025.
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had an excellent experience with Community from the start with the estimate process, during the install, and the final inspection. They did what they said they would, came early, stayed late, had attention to detailed craftsmanship. I had daily check ins with the project manager and could contact him about any areas of concern. I would call them in the future and would recommend them!

Recent Jobs and Reviews

Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars based on 8 customer reviews

At a glance

Community Roofing has completed 10 jobs between September 2026 and October 2026.

The 8 customer reviews shown here average 4.9 out of 5.

The most recent job was on October 1, 2026.

Recent work covers Milwaukee, WI, Whitefish Bay, WI, Glendale, WI, Muskego, WI and Shorewood, WI.

Job Locations and Reviews

Josh F.
Josh F. Checked in
Our team tackled an aging, cracking modified bitumen roof and a failing chimney crown. We carefully dismantled the failing masonry chimney below the roof line and patched the opening with new deck boards. After removing the old roof down to the substrate, we installed 1/2" mechanically fastened ISO cover board. We then fully adhered a seamless 60-mil Mule-Hide EPDM rubber membrane using custom 26-gauge coated steel aprons along all edges and pitched roof transitions. We finished by installing new rubber stack boots with water stop mastic, detaching and resetting the existing gutters with proper straps and screws, and re-securing the original gutter guards. The home is now fully weather-sealed, streamlined, and leak-free.
Milwaukee, WI 53221
Wauwatosa, WI - A dual-system replacement addressed both sloped and flat roof areas for this home! Our crew stripped the single layer of asphalt shingles down to the deck, installed six feet of ice and water shield along eave edges, and laid a CertainTeed NorthGate shingle system in Silver Birch with Terra Bronze W-valleys, white drip edges, and white gutter aprons. On the low-slope roof, we stripped down to the decking, installed mechanically fastened ISOGARD HD cover board, treated 2x6 edge nailers, and fully adhered a black 60-mil EPDM rubber membrane with matching black metal aprons. Detailed work included removing the unused masonry chimney below the deck line, reinstalling the TV antenna, adding eight slant-back box vents, and updating lead stack flashings. Another Wauwatosa residence fully weather-sealed and restored!
Abel G.
Abel G. Checked in
A dual-system replacement addressed both sloped and flat roof areas for this home! Our crew stripped the single layer of asphalt shingles down to the deck, installed six feet of ice and water shield along eave edges, and laid a CertainTeed NorthGate shingle system in Silver Birch with Terra Bronze W-valleys, white drip edges, and white gutter aprons. On the low-slope roof, we stripped down to the decking, installed mechanically fastened ISOGARD HD cover board, treated 2x6 edge nailers, and fully adhered a black 60-mil EPDM rubber membrane with matching black metal aprons. Detailed work included removing the unused masonry chimney below the deck line, reinstalling the TV antenna, adding eight slant-back box vents, and updating lead stack flashings. Another Wauwatosa residence fully weather-sealed and restored!
Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Jason F.
Jason F. Checked in
Our team executed a thorough multi-phase renovation, transforming both the house and detached garage. We began by removing the old shingle layer on the house, installing 7/16" OSB re-decking, and laying a CertainTeed Landmark shingle system in Moiré Black. This was complemented by synthetic underlayment, 6 feet of eave ice & water shield, Desert Sand drip edges, black W-valleys, edge intake, and louvered ridge vents. We also installed reglet-cut steel chimney counter-flashing. The old vinyl siding was stripped, and both structures were wrapped in Tyvek, followed by the installation of 8" LP SmartSide Lap Siding in Garden Sage with Board & Batten accents, 4" LP outside corner posts, and Norandex Desert Sand aluminum soffit and 8" fascia. The project concluded with the installation of 187 LF of new 6" seamless aluminum gutters and 105 LF of 4" downspouts across both structures, ensuring a fully weather-sealed and restored property.
Sussex, WI 53089
Milwaukee, WI - Addressing multi-layer removal across a historic home guided this project on East Bradford Avenue in Milwaukee. Our crew stripped two layers of existing material—including asbestos shingles and old cedar shakes—down to the deck structure, laying a CertainTeed Landmark shingle system in Burnt Sienna protected by synthetic underlayment, six feet of eave ice and water shield, brown W-valleys, brown drip edges, and brown gutter aprons. Detailed flashing work included custom copper front porch sawtooth flashing, 26-gauge steel reglet-cut chimney counter-flashing, lead stack boots, a Zipper electrical mast boot, six slant-back box vents, and low-slope SBS Flintlastic modified bitumen over the eyebrow dormers with prepped stucco integration. Another historic Milwaukee residence fully protected, watertight, and expertly preserved!
Paul B.
Paul B. Checked in
Addressing multi-layer removal across a historic home guided this project on East Bradford Avenue in Milwaukee. Our crew stripped two layers of existing material—including asbestos shingles and old cedar shakes—down to the deck structure, laying a CertainTeed Landmark shingle system in Burnt Sienna protected by synthetic underlayment, six feet of eave ice and water shield, brown W-valleys, brown drip edges, and brown gutter aprons. Detailed flashing work included custom copper front porch sawtooth flashing, 26-gauge steel reglet-cut chimney counter-flashing, lead stack boots, a Zipper electrical mast boot, six slant-back box vents, and low-slope SBS Flintlastic modified bitumen over the eyebrow dormers with prepped stucco integration. Another historic Milwaukee residence fully protected, watertight, and expertly preserved!
Milwaukee, WI 53211
Review
From beginning to end it was an easy process. I was kept in the loop and updated when necessary. Wonderful job cleaning up work site at job completion
Amy - Muskego, WI 53150
Response from Community Roofing:

Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback, Amy! We are thrilled to hear that you found the process easy and appreciated our communication and site cleanup. Your satisfaction means the world to our team!

Milwaukee, WI - Our team addressed significant deck gaps and moisture concerns with a comprehensive dual-structure project. We began by removing the existing asphalt roofing from both the house and the detached garage. We then applied 7/16" OSB re-decking over the original roof boards to create a solid foundation and ensure full warranty compliance. For the shingle system, we installed CertainTeed Landmark in Resawn Shake, supported by 6 feet of ice and water shield on heated eave edges, synthetic underlayment, and brown pre-finished steel W-valleys. Our metalwork included white aluminum drip edges, new plumbing stack flashings, Broan-style anti-draft-back vents, and a 26-gauge steel chimney flashing with a continuous reglet-cut finish in brown. The project successfully updated, reinforced, and weather-sealed the structures.
Jason F.
Jason F. Checked in
Our team addressed significant deck gaps and moisture concerns with a comprehensive dual-structure project. We began by removing the existing asphalt roofing from both the house and the detached garage. We then applied 7/16" OSB re-decking over the original roof boards to create a solid foundation and ensure full warranty compliance. For the shingle system, we installed CertainTeed Landmark in Resawn Shake, supported by 6 feet of ice and water shield on heated eave edges, synthetic underlayment, and brown pre-finished steel W-valleys. Our metalwork included white aluminum drip edges, new plumbing stack flashings, Broan-style anti-draft-back vents, and a 26-gauge steel chimney flashing with a continuous reglet-cut finish in brown. The project successfully updated, reinforced, and weather-sealed the structures.
Milwaukee, WI 53215
Matthew B.
Matthew B. Checked in
Our team addressed water intrusion on specific shingled roof areas, ensuring a comprehensive update. We removed existing asphalt shingles down to the structure, installing a 7/16" OSB re-decking layer over the original roof boards to meet full manufacturer warranty standards. We then applied a CertainTeed Landmark shingle system in Heather Blend, backed by six feet of ice and water shield membrane on heated eaves, full synthetic underlayment, and Terra Bronze metal valleys. Additional work included replacing the north facet bathroom vent, removing an unused satellite dish, and installing new step and wall flashings. We also installed custom Reglet-cut 26-gauge steel chimney counter-flashing in Terra Bronze, ensuring the home is fully weather-sealed and protected against future interior leaks.
Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Matthew B.
Matthew B. Checked in
Tearing off a single layer of aging asphalt down to the roof boards prepared this steep-pitch residence for a complete weatherproofing upgrade in Milwaukee! Our crew installed 7/16" OSB re-decking before laying a CertainTeed Landmark PRO shingle system in Max Def Red Oak, backed by six feet of ice and water shield along heated eaves, synthetic underlayment, and pre-finished brown W-style metal valleys. Specialty craftsmanship included mimicking historic sawtooth step flashing along the front wall facade while applying straight reglet-cut steel counter-flashing on the sides and back, installing an oversized chimney flashing with a custom cricket, fabricating a metal pan transition area, and re-flashing around the existing skylight. We completed the job by updating lead pipe stack boots, adding a Broan bath vent, setting up a ridge vent system to match the existing attic airflow, and reattaching the original gutters with new heavy-duty aluminum fascia brackets and screws.
Milwaukee, WI 53208
Milwaukee, WI - Our team successfully completed a comprehensive roof overhaul, starting with the removal of two layers of aged asphalt shingles. We installed 7/16" OSB re-decking over the original tongue-and-groove boards, ensuring full manufacturer warranty compliance. We then applied a CertainTeed NorthGate Class 4 impact-resistant shingle system, protected by 6 feet of WinterGuard ice and water shield. Additional features included synthetic underlayment, pre-finished steel W-valleys, aluminum drip edges, and gutter aprons. Our complete penetration detailing involved new step and wall flashings, plumbing stack flashings, and custom vents. The project concluded with a full water management upgrade, featuring new 6" seamless aluminum gutters and matching downspouts.
Paul B.
Paul B. Checked in
Our team successfully completed a comprehensive roof overhaul, starting with the removal of two layers of aged asphalt shingles. We installed 7/16" OSB re-decking over the original tongue-and-groove boards, ensuring full manufacturer warranty compliance. We then applied a CertainTeed NorthGate Class 4 impact-resistant shingle system, protected by 6 feet of WinterGuard ice and water shield. Additional features included synthetic underlayment, pre-finished steel W-valleys, aluminum drip edges, and gutter aprons. Our complete penetration detailing involved new step and wall flashings, plumbing stack flashings, and custom vents. The project concluded with a full water management upgrade, featuring new 6" seamless aluminum gutters and matching downspouts.
Milwaukee, WI 53211
Kelli J.
Kelli J. Checked in
Our team addressed localized storm damage, ensuring every affected section was restored. We removed loose shingles to inspect the decking and underlayment, replacing any compromised materials. Prepping the substrate with new underlayment, we installed CertainTeed Landmark PRO field shingles in Evergreen, matching the existing roofing patterns. Ridge cap shingles were added to seal the ridge line, ensuring complete water-shedding protection. The home is now weather-sealed and fully restored.
Milwaukee, WI 53211
Abel G.
Abel G. Checked in
Our team meticulously stripped an asphalt layer, exposing the deck structure for a comprehensive exterior upgrade. We installed six feet of ice and water shield along heated eaves and around all roof penetrations. Next, we laid a CertainTeed Landmark shingle system in Moiré Black, supported by synthetic underlayment. The project included detailed metalwork, such as 30' white aluminum drip edges, 30' white gutter aprons, black pre-finished W-valleys, step/wall flashings, and 26-gauge reglet-cut steel chimney counter-flashing. We also installed new plumbing vent stack flashings, two anti-draft-back Broan bath vents, and a louver-style ridge vent. Finally, we detached, re-pitched, and resecured the existing gutters with heavy-duty aluminum fascia brackets and screws. Another Glendale property fully weather-sealed, properly ventilated, and protected for years to come!
Glendale, WI 53209
Review
Satisfied Customer
Lucinda - Shorewood, WI 53211
Review
My new roof is gorgeous, and the entire process was far exceeded any expectations I had. I got 6 different quotes for my new roof, and I knew I was going with Community Roofing from the first time I Met Jason Faulkner, the man who came to assess the job and give me the initial quote. He was not a salesman, he was a down to earth; boots on the ground experienced guy who walked me through many of the things he instantly was able to assess with my particular home. His honest and straightforward approach was beyond any of the other 5 companies I explored and he ended up giving me the best quote anyway, based on my needs. The next step was scheduling the job and I met Kelli Jory who was the project manager and stuck with me from the scheduling thru the final walk thru. Her communication was incredible and as things came up, she calls directly explaining everything and working with my schedule. She was also boots on the ground; day 1, there on property and up before I was just to be sure the dumpster was placed in the right location. No other company does that. Then the most important part, full tear off and installing of roof, began with a crew of over half a dozen of the most hard working, experienced, competent bunch of friendly, accommodating and efficient team of carpenters and craftsman I have ever seen. They finished the whole job in two days, including my garage roof which ended up having quite a bit of unforeseen underlayment rotted boards to replace. They kept an impeccable job site tryout with team members picking up construction material and nails while in progress. Weather is always an issue, and knowing there was a possibility of rain the morning after day 1, they continued to work into the night with headlamps on to ensure the half open roof was sealed and tarped and secure. Community Roofing is wonderful, my new roof and gutters are gorgeous and I could not be happier with my choice. You can save yourself a lot of time searching by having them out to quote your next job. I don’t often write long reviews like this, but that is how beyond expectation they went. Thank you to Jason, Kelli, and that beautiful team of craftsmen I had for my home. Patty
Patricia - Whitefish Bay, WI 53217
Response from Community Roofing:

Patty, thank you so much for this incredible review and for trusting us with your home! Jason, Kelli, and our entire crew are thrilled to hear about your experience, and we truly appreciate you taking the time to share these kind words about our team. We're so happy you love your new roof!

Review
Great group of men & communication throughout;
Mary - Milwaukee, WI 53207
Review
My entire experience with your team was great from sales to the installation crew.
Matt - Milwaukee, WI 53207
Review
I feel fortunate to have discovered Community Roofing! Above all they are a trustworthy team and gave me a great price on a new roof and gutters. I have a very tall, steep roof and many places want to up charge for that. Community Roofers were trustworthy from the quote to the finished work.
Sarah - Milwaukee, WI 53212
Review
Excellent service
Stephanie - Milwaukee, WI 53205
Review
Top notch work, from taking the time with me up-front (being patient and helping me work through the choices) through installation (looks great & very minimal cleanup on my part afterward) and follow-up (back a day later to tack down 1 shingle that I didn't notice; also came back weeks later to talk to the attic insulation crew who initially though there was some water intrusion but it was from years earlier).
Steve - West Allis, WI 53219